A Four-Step Process to Find Your Niche Without Pulling Your Hair Out

If you're running a $10M manufacturing operation and looking to break through to the next level, you've got to make sure you're dominating a specific space–not just competing in the general market.

You've already proven you can build a successful business. You've got the equipment, the team, and the track record. But if you're honest about your growth over the last few years, you know there's untapped potential sitting on the table.

Maybe you're still taking on work that doesn't move the needle. Maybe you're competing on price more than you'd like. Or maybe when someone asks, "What makes you different?" you give an answer that sounds a lot like what your competitors would say.

Here's the thing: at $10M, you can't afford to be everything to everyone anymore. The manufacturers crushing it at $20M, $50M, and beyond aren't there because they do more of the same work. They got there by owning a specific niche that customers will pay a premium for.

So if you're serious about scaling past where you are now, you need to answer four critical questions. These will help you refine what you're offering, who you're selling to, and how you're positioning yourself in the market.

Question #1 – What problem are you uniquely positioned to solve?

You're not starting from scratch here. You already solve problems for your customers every day. But here's the question: are you solving a problem that only a handful of manufacturers can solve, or are you solving one that any shop with the right equipment can handle?

Because if it's the latter, you're competing on price and availability. And that's a race to the bottom.

Think about the work that comes through your door. What are the projects where customers specifically sought you out? What capabilities do you have that make certain jobs easier for you than they are for your competitors?

Maybe it's your ability to work with difficult materials. Maybe it's your tolerance capabilities. Maybe it's your certifications or your lead times on complex assemblies.

Whatever it is, that's where your growth is hiding. You need to double down on the problems that you're set up to solve better than anyone else–not just the problems that keep the lights on.

Question #2 – Who actually needs what you're best at?

You've probably got a wide range of customers right now. Some are great. Some are a pain. Some pay well. Some nickel-and-dime you on every quote.

The ones you want more of? They're not random. They fit a pattern.

Who are your best customers? What industries are they in? What size companies are they? What problems do they come to you with? What's their approval process like, and how much are they spending annually?

You need to get specific here. "Anyone who needs machining" isn't an answer. "Medical device companies doing low-volume, high-precision work with exotic alloys" is an answer.

If you don't know who your ideal customer is, you're spending your marketing dollars and sales time chasing work that doesn't fit. You're quoting jobs you shouldn't take and losing jobs you should have won.

Build out a profile of who you're actually trying to sell to. Then go find more of them.

Question #3 – How badly do they need it solved?

This is where a lot of manufacturers get stuck. You might have the capability. You might have the customer. But if the problem you're solving isn't urgent enough, you're going to fight on price every single time.

Let's say you want to invest in a new 5-axis machine that costs $800,000. You figure you can offer faster turnarounds and tighter tolerances. Great. But if your customers don't actually need faster turnarounds or tighter tolerances enough to pay for it, that machine just became a very expensive paperweight.

Price is the reality check. If you're constantly justifying your quotes or losing work to cheaper competitors, it's not because your pricing is wrong. It's because the customer doesn't feel the pain badly enough to pay what it costs to solve it right.

You want customers who are already looking for the solution you provide–not ones you have to convince. You want them walking in the door saying, "We need someone who can handle this, and we know it's not going to be cheap."

If you're doing the convincing, you're in the wrong market.

Question #4 – Why should they choose you over everyone else?

Alright, so you've figured out the problem, you know who has it, and you know they're willing to pay to solve it. Now comes the hard part: why you?

Because let's be real–there are other shops that can machine parts. There are other manufacturers with certifications. There are other companies that say they have fast lead times and great quality.

So what makes you different?

This is where most manufacturers fall flat. They list the same things everyone else does: quality, service, on-time delivery. That's not differentiation. That's table stakes.

Here's what actually sets manufacturers apart:

• Production capacity flexibility – You can handle a 10,000-piece order or a 10-piece prototype without making the customer feel like they're too small or too big
• Proprietary processes or equipment – You've got machines, tooling, or methods that competitors literally can't replicate
• Vertical integration – You control enough of the supply chain that you're not at the mercy of outside vendors for quality or lead times
• Material specialization – You know how to work with materials that other shops won't touch or don't understand
• Rapid prototyping to production – A customer can go from concept to full production with you, no handoffs to another manufacturer
• Certifications that matter – You've got AS9100, ISO 13485, ITAR, or other credentials that unlock contracts your competitors can't even bid on

Pick the one or two things you legitimately do better than anyone else. Then build your entire sales and marketing message around that.

Stop trying to be good at everything. Be the best at something specific.

The bottom line

These four questions aren't easy to answer. They require you to turn down work that doesn't fit. They require you to get honest about what you're actually great at. And they require you to stop thinking like a $10M manufacturer trying to do a little bit of everything.

But if you can nail this down, you stop competing with every other shop in your region. You start competing with the two or three manufacturers in the country who do what you do. And that's when your pricing power, your margins, and your growth trajectory completely change.

You've already built a solid business. Now it's time to build a dominant one.

‍